Gary Turk’s poem about the dangers of our always connected technology is being called life-changing. If haven’t see the video, it argues:
- We spend nearly all of our time looking at a screen.
- We have traded true interaction for shallow, safe virtual intimacy.
- Our iPhones and Galaxy S5’s have become our masters.
- We are lonely because of our technology, not in spite of it.
Ironically, this video has gone viral on the very social networks it claims to hate.
Idealism Sells
Turk’s message is an overly simplistic one. Social networks are inherently bad, and everything else is naturally good. It seems as though Turk cannot imagine carrying a smart phone outside, and still enjoying the outside. He mentioned being able to enjoy the birth of your daughter because you didn’t bring your phone. He spoke of not having any friends around because a “group message will do.” He said we use social media because we “crave adulation.” Turk is definitely right in attacking these attitudes, but to make it an either/or scenario is simplistic and ignorant.
If I had missed the births of my two children because I was too busy sitting in the corner reading my Facebook new feed, then I have a problem. The problem, though, is not Facebook. It’s me. If a group message to my friends suffices for both them and me, then the problem is not iMessages. The problem is us. If I create a better, more fascinating online persona, then the problem is not Twitter. It’s my insecurity. If I climb a mountain and want to send a picture of my victory to everyone I know, that does not mean I am missing my victory. It means I am sharing my victory in a way that was never possible before.
Balance in All Things
What if instead of quitting our social networks we used them well? When my daughter was born, I was posting updates on Facebook. Not to brag or because I needed my social media “hit.” I lived in California with friends and family spread out over the whole US. I could have called or texted them each individually, instead. But then I would missed the entire birth because I wasn’t using social media. One could argue I could have waited until the delivery was over and then make phone calls. To which I say I could also have mailed them a letter once it was over. I don’t think my mom, in Nicaragua, would have appreciated that.
Social media is an amazing tool for communicating with, and hearing from, dozens or hundreds of our friends. Can it become consuming? Sure. But so can dieting, alcohol, TV, and work. Should we all put those things down and go play at the park like we used to when were kids? Social media is not bad. Technology is not bad.
Obsessive behavior is bad.